[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428055897.png' id='42844']
This article originally appeared on VICE UK.
We were promised a
confusing punch-up, but it was more like a tightly choreographed fight scene in
a revival of West Side Story. In the end, all the key players had so much to
lose (and very little to win) that the Leaders' Debate quickly turned into a
series of ticked boxes, as the politicos deliberately tried not to test each
other's boundaries, instead engaging in some kind of tacit mutual pact to stick
to their individual scripts.
So if it felt a bit formulaic, then maybe, just maybe, that's because it was. After all, at least 14 oft-repeated tropes formed part of a debate that went on longer than most Tarkovsky films. For ease of reference, we've listed them below.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428055920.png' id='42845']
THE WEIRDO
WHO GETS TO POSE AS A "MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC"
The first question, as
ever on these occasions, came from a 12-year-old child prodigy in a suit who
looked like he was vying to be the William Hague of 2032. He even went by the improbable
name of Johnny Tudor—a sort of English Heritage take on Johnny Bravo, and
exactly the kind of crap marginal seat-superhero who wanted to know
uninteresting things about the deficit that he could have just looked up on the
internet anyway.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428055968.png' id='42846']
THE HIGHLY TRADITIONAL
ATTEMPT TO DIFFERENTIATE POLICIES THAT ARE ALL THE SAME
In answering him, all
of the parties then did their best angel-pin-head-dance to try and tell you why
they were, a) unbelievably financially responsible when it came to the economy,
but b) totally going to give you lots of free cool shit, from tax breaks for
chihuahuas to free Now TV subscriptions with every hernia operation you ordered
on the NHS.
It turned out that all
the parties have different platforms on cutting the deficit. Some of them will
cut it reaaaaallly slowly at first then reeaaaaaallly quickly at the end. Some
will cut it reaaaaallly quickly at first then reeaaaaaallly slowly at the end.
Some will cut it reaaallly slowly in the middle, then use that bit to cut
around the edges slightly faster. Some will cut it in strips. Some will cut it
in a mobius pattern. In summary: everyone would like to cut the deficit but
everyone would also like to spend your money.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428056009.png' id='42847']
THE OFTEN-REPEATED
DEBATING FALLBACK YOU WISH THEY'D FORGET
David Cameron's
severely disabled son died at the age of six, in NHS care. That is so very
horrible. But perhaps, David, the best way to memorialize young Ivan Cameron
would be
not to use him as a debating point every time your back
is against the wall over funding the NHS? Perhaps it would be to go for a long
stroll in a quiet garden, and think fondly about the time he said he was scared
of monsters and you tucked him in and told him "there are no monsters here, my
boy, sleep tight now," and then let a single tear pucker onto your waxy
cheek and drop down onto the frosty mid-Winter grass? Amiright or
amiright?
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428056054.png' id='42849']
THE MELANIE PHILLIPS ON QUESTION TIME MEMORIAL AWARD FOR SEVERE
COMPASSION FAILURE
There's telling
Bulgarians they should get to the back of the social housing line, and then
there's telling several thousand AIDS patients to go die. When Farage accused NHS AIDS patients who are not British nationals of health tourism, it seemed to stumble
into the middle of the room and just lie there for a few minutes before anyone
else could figure out a way to respond to it, like being told you have cancer,
or, um, AIDS.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428056906.png' id='42868']
THE CRASHINGLY OBVIOUS
TWITTER GAG YOU SAW IN EIGHT DIFFERENT FORMS
Was that Farage was
going to tell Natalie Bennet to piss off back to her native Australia.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428056078.png' id='42850']
THE SADLY UNAVOIDABLE
POINTLESSNESS OF THE MINNOWS
For viewers already
puzzled by Natalie Bennett, the inclusion of Plaid Cymru's own PolBot 3000
model, Leanne Wood, was pretty much the final straw. Wood commands a party
that isn't even in power in a country that comprises one in 20 voters. She is basically less important than the 15th most senior person in the Labour
Party, and her policy platform seems to be, "to be a less interesting SNP." For most viewers who hadn't considered Welsh politics in years, the mere sight
of Plaid Cymru was enough to make them realize that this disastrous Union
experiment had gone on long enough.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428056117.png' id='42851']
THE HAMMERING OF THE THINGS THE FOCUS GROUPS LIKED IN THE LAST DEBATE
After he lost the
polls but won the Twitter war last time out, Eddie's people had evidently
picked up on his "good points" in the last (non) debate, and decided to make him
amplify them. So we had Ed the Super-Passionate, his voice quimming with hoity
emotion as he bleated about the NHS, sounding every bit like he was having his
prostate milked by a gorgeous young proctologist. This tactic still seems to be
working for him, and at this stage it's a case of "something's got to."
THE MUCH-TRAILED
HARPING ON ZERO HOURS
Then, sensing blood in
Cameron's wobble in front of Paxman over zero hours contracts, Ed's people had
decided to crack that peanut with a diamond-drill jackhammer. After 120
minutes of him thumping them from all angles, it began to sound like this was
everything to him. A week ago, no one knew what they were. Now, it sounded like
Miliband's dad had been killed by a Contract Killer on Zero Hours and he'd
sworn an oath on the brow of Primrose Hill to avenge him.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428056144.png' id='42853']
THE INEVITABLE LIB DEM
RETURN TO MIDDLING-OUT
Do you want to cut a
lot? Do you want to cut a little? What if it all just seems a bit confusing and
makes your head hurt when you try and decide who's right or wrong? Then
obviously you should be voting Lib Dem. Often accused of being
wishy-washy, Clegg was actively turning insipidness into his USP by using his
closing speech to announce that he'd cut less than the Tories, more than
Labour. That was why he deserved your vote: because he's a sort of wibbly
public school Goldilocks.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428056213.png' id='42854']
THE AWKWARD STAGED RHETORICAL FLOURISHES
Of all the creaking
staged bits of rhetoric, probably the most tiresome was Nick Clegg trying to
call out Ed Miliband on whether he would "apologize for Labour's economic mess." No, wait, it wasn't that at all. It was when David Cameron, super-cringe,
claimed to have a copy of the note Liam Byrne left in the Treasury when Labour
departed
on his actual lectern. No, wait. Tell a lie. Of course, it
was Ed Miliband found himself falling back on the most famously effective
payoff line in US Presidential debate history. Ronald Reagan's jibes to Jimmy
Carter, "There you go again." Yes, Ed was effectively being a covers band of
the founding father of neo-conservatism. Michael Foot would've been so proud.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428056322.png' id='42856']
THE HECKLER
The inevitable heckler
arrived, inevitably, in the final quarter. "How would you like to clean up your
own mother's piss?" Well, David Cameron liked it just fine, he supposed,
because his heckler had made the tactical error of trying to make a serious
point about soldiers' after-service care while wearing a furry white gilet and
being a dick. As Victoria Prosser—whose Twitter profile describes her as a
"mum, coach, artist, wellbeing guru!"—was removed by security, Cameron merely
confirmed that he loved Our Boys very much, before noting that a woman in a furry
gilet who called herself a "well-being guru" shouldn't expect the public to get
behind her.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428056343.png' id='42857']
THE USE OF CANCELING TRIDENT TO BANKROLL EVERYTHING
Trident is a
submarine-launched ballistic missile (SLBM) equipped with multiple
independently targetable re-entry vehicles (MIRV). It costs around $3.6 billion
a year to run, which is only 15 percent of the Defense budget. Replacing it in
a few years time will cost another $30 billion. Yet every minnow party in
history from the Lib Dems to the Greens still uses it as their financial black
hole-plastering device whenever they want to get out of a spending commitment
they've made about free woggles for llamas. This they do by valuing it at "$150 billion" and neglecting to measure that this figure is for the full 30 years.
Nicola Sturgeon managed to take up the cudgels against it more than once.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428057779.png' id='42871']
THE INEVITABLE MASSIVE
POLICY AREA OMISSION
It's just a good thing
there isn't much global conflict going on, or else our sclerotic, insular
island nation might've had to answer a question on international affairs. Given
that the debate was already two hours of gray gruel, this was merciful. On the
downside, it was an omission that meant that no one would split their sides
hearing what Plaid's independent Wales would do if 300,000 fiercely-armed
Russian troops lined up in the Baltic, nor hear Natalie Bennett suggest that we
should let ISIS live in accordance with their traditional customs and stop
trying to impose Western morality on them.
[body_image width='640' height='400' path='images/content-images/2015/04/03/' crop='images/content-images-crops/2015/04/03/' filename='the-seven-way-leaders-debate-734-body-image-1428056595.png' id='42865']
THE UNCOMFORTABLY
PREDICTABLE MEDIA PUZZLEMENT
Afterward, the snap
polls simply told us that Cameron and Miliband were neck and neck—which
probably says more about tribalism in politics than anything clear. Was there a
winner? Not even "democracy" was a real winner here, but over the coming days
any polls bounce will be reverse-correlated back to the debates. Pundits gazed
at their feet and wondered whether it would all start to mean something soon
enough. Is this election campaign actually ever going to generate momentum, or,
given that we've spent the better part of a year fighting the phoney war, have
we all made up our minds already? Are we now simply drifting toward May 7 in exactly the pattern of electoral gridlock the polls keeping
suggesting? They're not always wrong, y'know.
Follow Gavin on Twitter.
Check out more of VICE's UK Election '15 coverage